The pickleball world is in the middle of a scoring debate. Traditional side-out scoring has been the standard since the sport began, but rally scoring — where every rally results in a point — is gaining momentum in professional play. Here is what you need to know about both formats and what the shift means for the sport.
What is Side-Out Scoring?
Side-out scoring is the traditional format used in recreational and most competitive pickleball. Under this system:
- Only the serving team can score points
- If the receiving team wins a rally, they earn the serve (a "side-out") but not a point
- In doubles, each team gets two serves (one per player) before a side-out, except at the start of the game
- Games are typically played to 11 points, win by 2
- The score has three numbers in doubles (server score - receiver score - server number)
What is Rally Scoring?
Rally scoring is simpler: every rally results in a point, regardless of who served.
- Win the rally = win a point, whether serving or receiving
- Games are typically played to 21 points, win by 2 (higher total because points are scored every rally)
- Only two numbers in the score (your score - their score)
- Each team gets one serve per side-out (not two)
- Freeze rule at 20: must win serving (prevents games going on forever)
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Aspect | Side-Out Scoring | Rally Scoring |
|---|---|---|
| Points awarded | Only to serving team | To either team every rally |
| Game to | 11 (win by 2) | 21 (win by 2) |
| Score format (doubles) | Three numbers (4-3-1) | Two numbers (12-9) |
| Serves per side-out | 2 (both partners serve) | 1 (single serve per side-out) |
| Average game duration | 15-25 min (unpredictable) | 12-18 min (more predictable) |
| Comeback potential | Higher (can hold serve without giving up points) | Lower (every lost rally costs a point) |
| Learning curve | Steeper (three-number scoring) | Easier (two-number scoring) |
| TV broadcast friendly | Hard to schedule due to variable length | Predictable timing |
Why is Rally Scoring Being Adopted?
The push for rally scoring is driven by several factors:
- Broadcasting: TV networks need predictable match durations. Side-out games can vary wildly in length
- Pace of play: Rally scoring eliminates "dead" rallies where no points are scored, making games feel more consequential
- Simplicity: Two numbers is easier for new players and spectators to follow than three
- MLP adoption: Major League Pickleball uses rally scoring, giving it significant visibility
- Tournament scheduling: More predictable game lengths make scheduling easier for tournament directors
The Case for Keeping Side-Out Scoring
Many players — especially recreational players — prefer the traditional format:
- Comeback potential: A team that is behind can hold serve without losing ground, building momentum for a comeback
- Strategic depth: The serving/receiving dynamic adds a layer of strategy
- Tradition: It is how most players learned and how the sport has been played for decades
- Rec play flow: In casual play, the variable game length is not a problem — and the serving rotation creates natural rhythm
💡There is no "better" scoring system — it depends on context. Rally scoring works great for professional broadcasts and time-limited events. Side-out scoring works great for recreational play and community events where pace is less critical.
How Rally Scoring Changes Strategy
Rally scoring is not just a rule change — it changes how the game is played:
- Every point matters equally: There are no "free" rallies. Unforced errors are more costly
- Return of serve is more aggressive: Since receivers can score, there is incentive to be more offensive on return
- Serving advantage decreases: In side-out, serving is a scoring opportunity. In rally, the serve advantage is less pronounced
- Consistency is king: With every rally counting, the most consistent team wins more often than the team with flashy but risky shots
- Freeze rule strategy: At 20 points, the serving team must win the rally to win. This creates a unique end-game dynamic
Where Are We in 2026?
The scoring landscape in 2026:
- MLP: Uses rally scoring (games to 21)
- PPA Tour: Has experimented with rally scoring in select events
- USA Pickleball: Sanctioned events still predominantly use side-out scoring
- Recreational play: Overwhelmingly side-out scoring
- Trend: Professional play is moving toward rally scoring; rec play is staying with side-out
What Should Tournament Organizers Do?
If you run tournaments, consider your audience:
- Recreational/community events: Stick with side-out scoring. It is what your players know
- Competitive/open events: Consider rally scoring for tighter scheduling and exposure to the pro format
- Mixed approach: Use side-out for pool play and rally scoring for elimination rounds
- Communicate clearly: Whatever you choose, make the scoring format crystal clear in event registration
Support Both Scoring Formats
PickleballScorer supports both side-out and rally scoring. Switch formats per event or per match — the app handles the rules automatically.
Try PickleballScorerRelated Articles
How to Score Pickleball Matches with PickleballScorer: Simple vs Advanced Mode
Complete guide to scoring matches on PickleballScorer. Learn when to use Simple Mode vs Advanced Mode, understand individual points, break points, serve faults, and every button on the scoring screen.
Pickleball Scoring Rules Explained Simply (With Examples)
Everything you need to know about pickleball scoring — singles, doubles, the 0-0-2 start, rally scoring, and common mistakes. The only scoring guide you need.